Do We Give Too Much Weight to Outsider Opinions? Unpacking a Toxic Tradition

Do We Give Too Much Weight to Outsider Opinions? Unpacking a Toxic Tradition

Have you ever caught yourself fretting over a stranger's throwaway comment? If you're nodding along, you might be a bit like Dr. Karl Reid, a black MIT graduate whose reaction to a stereotypical assumption became a springboard for an intriguing discussion: Why do we care so much about what white people think of us?

Dr. Reid’s experience is not unique. Picture this: a highly accomplished individual, adorned in MIT apparel, gets asked if he played basketball for the school. Not engineering, not science—basketball. It’s a moment that could make one chuckle at its absurdity if it weren’t so telling of the deeper societal scripts at play.

In a recent video, which sparked quite the conversation online, I dove into this phenomenon. Dr. Reid, despite his towering academic and professional achievements, felt compelled to address a stranger’s narrow perspective publicly. This raises a compelling question: Why do the opinions and assumptions of white people bother us so deeply, especially when they come from someone we may never see again?


This isn't just about Dr. Reid feeling underestimated or typecast; it's about a pervasive issue within our culture where the views of certain demographics disproportionately affect us. Is it because their opinions have historically held more power, or because we are conditioned to seek validation from these groups?

Here on Broken Traditions, we challenge these toxic norms. We push back against the idea that someone else's view can define our worth, particularly when those views are mired in stereotypes and outdated beliefs. But breaking free from this mindset isn't easy—it's woven into the very fabric of our interactions.

So, how do we start changing this? It begins with self-awareness and a hefty dose of introspection. Next time you find yourself ruminating over a remark, ask yourself:

  • Why does this opinion matter to me?
  • What power am I allowing this person to have over my self-esteem?
  • How can I detach my self-worth from the perceptions of others?

These aren’t just rhetorical questions—they’re steps towards mental liberation. Dr. Reid’s response, while understandable, highlights a common trap that many of us fall into. By recognizing these moments, we can start to react differently.

The goal here isn’t to become indifferent but rather to reach a place where such comments are seen for what they are: mere opinions, not definitions. We must learn to hold our sense of self so high that no offhand comment can shake it. We're talking about fostering a mindset where we can hear someone’s limited view, and instead of getting defensive, we smile, knowing their opinion doesn't change who we are or diminish our accomplishments.

Dr. Reid’s experience on that plane isn’t just a personal anecdote; it’s a reflection of a broader issue that many face. And while his response was to tweet, ours might be to simply move on, knowing that in the grand scheme of things, these opinions are as fleeting as the people who hold them.

Let’s open up this discussion: Have you found yourself giving undue weight to someone’s opinion just because of their racial or social background? How do you handle it, and what steps can you take to empower yourself against such biases?

Drop your thoughts in the comments below—let’s break these traditions, one thought at a time.

Back to blog